to top

Worshipping Nonsense

It’s not so much a matter of ‘being versus non-being’ (although it is that as well) but ‘being versus pseudo-being’, which is infinitely more nuanced, infinitely more subtle. Pseudo-being is all we know! ‘Margarine is all we know‘, Russian mystic and philosopher Pyotr Demyanovich Uspensky tells us. Because pseudo-being has been so very effectively substituted for being we don’t see anything wrong with this set up, we don’t know that there’s anything amiss.

 

 

Pseudo-being works as a substitute for being, but that doesn’t mean that they have anything in common – it’s not as if PB is a kind of watered down or diluted version of the original ‘non-fake’ article. This is – therefore – Jean Baudrillard’s ‘perfect crime’ (or ‘perfect murder’). PB isn’t actually a real thing at all; it isn’t a real thing because it’s our own projection, our own device. Clearly we aren’t able to project Being itself – Being can’t be Being unless it stands up by itself. It can’t be a ‘fix’.

 

 

The point about Pseudo-Being is that it can be anything we want it to be (so to speak), whereas there is nothing even remotely arbitrary about Being. Being – we might say – is like space in this respect. Space can’t be arbitrary, obviously enough, only fixed things (or fixed points, or fixed ‘statements of fact’) can be that. Space isn’t localized -that would be a contradiction in terms! We could also say something to the effect that ‘There is only one way for the delocalized state to be’. It’s only when we’re dealing with the local situation (the Paradigm of Locality) there are of course very many different ways for things to be. This is reminiscent of the point Krishnamurti makes when he says that ‘reality is choiceless’.

 

 

In rough and ready kind of away we could say that PB is akin to ‘pretending’ – we can pretend to be anyone we want but who we are behind it all it is of course just the one person. There’s not lots of people pretending. PB can be ascribed or assigned to anything – it’s like saying that something is ‘super-special’ just because we say that it is. Precisely because of this therefore the whole thing becomes meaningless, the whole thing becomes a joke. On the other hand, if there’s no leeway at all (if there is zero chance of us ‘getting in’ there to manipulate things to suit ourselves) then this is a radically different kettle of fish. Only then can we talk about what is real – only when we’re not involved in it, only when it’s got ‘nothing to do with us’.

 

 

New Agers (as is well known) love to say that we ‘create our own reality’ but this is deceptive – we create our own pseudo-realities, our own biased or distrusted interpretation of the real thing and then act as if we did no such thing. We do it and say we didn’t, just as Berger and Luckmann say. It sounds empowering to say that we create our own reality, but in truth it’s not empowering at all – we are being empowered to deceive ourselves, which isn’t really such a great thing! To be gifted with the ability to fool ourselves with 100% efficiency (to be gifted with the unique ability to deceive ourselves without ever knowing about it) is ‘the empowerment of samsara’. And as Milarepa points out (not in these exact words), we’re not smart enough to fear samsara – we’re supremely oblivious to the danger involved. Or, as we read in the Lotus Sutra, it is as if we are small children playing in a burning house completely unaware of our great peril. We will never leave the burning house of our own accord.

 

 

Being – we might say – is absolutely impervious to any manipulation we might try on it. It’s immune – we don’t get to play our games with it. This doesn’t stop us trying of course – we carry on manipulating for all we worth, we carry on creating private universes for ourselves ten to the dozen, but in doing this we lose being and gain the dubious benefit of pseudo-being instead (which is as we have said functions very well as a substitute). It functions perfectly as a substitute because it blocks out all awareness of the real thing (just as a brick wall will block out the light of the day). This is the only way can function – it can only function when there’s no competition, when there’s no sign or indication of the real thing. Because we don’t ‘know any better’ therefore we worship nonsense as if it were the most holy of all sacred truths. ‘A fool is excited by every word’, says Heraclitus.

 

 

The point we’re making here is that pseudo-being isn’t really ‘a thing in itself’. It looks like there are actual honest-to-goodness possibilities in it but there are never going to be any possibilities in a private, self-referential universe. There are no possibilities inherent in that situation where we are ‘wholly engaged in relating to our own projected reality as if it was not a projected reality’. We can play our games without any impediment, but everything that happens in a game gets ‘cancelled out’ later on – we might seem to be getting somewhere but sooner or later we’re going to find out that this wasn’t really the case. When we live in a world that is made up of a biased account of ‘what reality is’ then thought – being itself a bias – cannot do anything in an unbiased way. Thought is a bias, and everything that comes out of it equals that very same bias. Thought can never invent anything, it can only repeat itself (whilst claiming that it is not doing so).

 

 

When we try to interact with the world on the basis of a biased viewpoint (which we don’t acknowledge as such) then all we’re ever going to get back is that very same bias. It’s going to be reflected right back at us so that it forms a loop, so that it produces a closed system. When a bias gets reflected back at us it undoes itself, we could say. It negates itself just as a circle negates itself, just as vibration negates itself. If a circle did not turn in on itself – so as to ‘undo what it had only just achieved’ – then wouldn’t be a circle. If a vibration didn’t keep on ‘repeating itself’ then it wouldn’t be a vibration.  If an eddy (which is to say, a ‘local vortex’) didn’t keep going around and around on the spot then it would cease to be an eddy, it would cease to be a vortex. It would cease to be ‘local’ and – thus – it would disappear off our radar screens.

 

 

If we want a concrete or literal reality to live out the course of our lives in (so as to live in an ‘ontologically unchallenged’ way) then circular motion is the only way to achieve this. ‘Self-reference’ (i.e., ‘relating only to oneself’) is the only way to achieve this. The only way to obtain a positive reality – a reality of which we can at all times be sure and certain – is to cause reality to ‘curve back in on itself’ (which is a topological way of saying that it ‘agrees with itself’). Self-agreement ensures a hermetic seal around our so-called ‘world’, it ensures that there is no ‘competition’, no chance of the bias ever being shown up for what it is. The vibration (or circularity) is the brick wall that protects us from any outside influence – it protects us from knowing that there even is ‘an outside’. The vibration (or vortex) produces a logically consistent – and therefore ontologically unchallenging – world for us to live in, but at the same time it renders this consistent life of ours wholly and irredeemably meaningless. We can derive no meaning from a circle, from a ‘revolving loop of logic’. Pseudo-being is ‘being that suits our hidden bias’, we could therefore say, and this is no being at all. Far from being anything real, it’s just the activity of thought.

 

 

It might sound somewhat obscure to be talking in terms of ‘invisible’ or ‘hidden’ biases but what we’re on about here is a lot more straightforward than it might sound. The point isn’t hugely difficult to understand: When we interact with the world on the basis of a bias, on the basis of something we have already decided upon but not admitting to having done so, then instead of an ‘open universe’ (a universe that has no limits, a universe that doesn’t ‘collapse in on itself’) we end up with a closed one, we end up with a state of perfect tautological self-agreement. This state expresses itself in terms of YES and NO which – it would seem – absolutely don’t agree with each other! We don’t see YES as agreeing with NO, after all. What is going on here however is Alan Watts’ ‘Game of Black and White’. The story is that <Black> and <White> are two entirely different things, the story is that they are fundamentally opposing forces (like GOOD and EVIL) but this is merely the disguise which covers up the fact that the two opposites are secretly in agree with each other the whole time. That’s ‘the game’, and just as long as we continue to play this game we won’t see how stuck we are. Just as long as we continue to immerse ourselves in The Game of Black and White we won’t be able to see ‘the barrenness of samsara’ (which is without any question at all the most frightening thing there is)…

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Image credit – slash.film

 

 

 

Leave a Comment

nine − 7 =