All systems are the same system, and this generic (or ‘all-purpose’) system operates by converting everything into itself. That’s the way the system works, that’s simply how it does things. Whatever terms it is that we start off with gets used to interpret everything that follows, with the result that – in the end – nothing exists that disagrees with these terms, runs counter to them, etc.
We could also say that this is the way the self-concept works – it operates by re-writing or reformatting everything in its own image. It puts its own slant on stuff. This is the only way it has of interacting with its environment – by imposing itself on that environment, by unconsciously projecting itself onto everything it comes across. It imposes its own take on everything it comes across, and its own take is itself.
If we were a psychologically mature culture then we would understand this key principle, but we aren’t and we don’t; we only understand stuff from our own arbitrary point of view and ‘understanding stuff from our own arbitrary point of view’ isn’t understanding, it’s ‘projecting’, which is the reverse of understanding. Understanding means being sensitive to what’s going on around us, and that’s the one thing a logical system can never be. Logic isn’t sensitive. Sensitivity is open-ended it doesn’t operate on the basis of preconceptions, on the basis of ‘what we already know’. It doesn’t operate on the basis of bias in other words, whilst this is precisely logic does. Logic can only register what matches its pre-existent categories – it exists in a universe made of itself.
Logic can never encounter anything new, and this is just another way of saying that it has no sensitivity. Logic is the very antithesis of sensitivity, as we have just said. Instead of registering what is there, it says what is there, it positively (or aggressively) asserts what is there. It cannot entertain the suggestion that maybe the universe isn’t at all what it says it is. It assumes that reality must be based on its own patented scheme of things, which it is constitutionally unable to question. It won’t accept uncertainty – it says that everything has to be either ‘this’ or ‘that’, and ‘this’ and ‘that’ are its own constructs.
We’re not just talking about two varying but related approaches here (i.e., the ‘sensitive’ versus the ‘insensitive’) – the one is the mirror image of the other. On the one hand there is actual connection with a greater or more expansive reality in the case of sensitivity, whilst on the other hand what we have is zero connection (which is what projection comes down to, as Jung has said). Instead of connection with a greater reality what we have is ‘the heedless imposition of our own private reality’, which we never examine, which we never see as such.
We can relate this to what Heraclitus says in Fragment 89: “The waking have one common world, but the sleeping turn aside each into a world of his own”. The crucial point to understand here is that we don’t realise that we’ve ‘turned aside into a world of our own’; the transition is seamless, imperceptible. The reason it’s seamless is because our personalised privatised version of the world – which is real only to us – replaces the unedited original. Nothing could be easier than to transition from ‘the world that is really there’ to the Projected World without knowing that we have done so. It’s a hole we fall down and never get out of – the ‘hole’ is reality as far as we are concerned.
We can also think of Jung’s often repeated quote, ‘Projection changes the world into a replica of one’s own unknown face’. There are two points here therefore – [1] is that we don’t spot it when the real world is replaced by the projected one, and [2] is that we that to live in the projected world (which is private to us) is to live in a cocoon since there’s no connection between our own ‘made up’ version of the world and the world that is actually there. This is our predicament. We have no clue that we are disconnected from reality, but we absolutely are all the same. The Private World isn’t a world at all, it’s just darkness, it’s just what happens when the ‘off switch’ for consciousness gets turned off – we get plunged into a darkness that we can’t see to be darkness. Consciousness gets replaced by a set of rules; it gets ‘modified in accordance with the conditioning that has been imposed on it by the tyrant which is thought’.
Consciousness cannot be modified to suit our biases without ceasing to be consciousness – just as the truth cannot be conveniently slanted to suit us without straightaway ceasing to be the truth. There’s no ‘picking and choosing’ when it comes to the truth. When we talk about ‘the inherent bias of logic’ – the bias that is embodied in a system of logic (and a system of logic is a set of biases or rules, nothing more) and ‘a prejudiced human being’ (who sees only what they want to see, who only sees what they are prejudiced to see) then it seems as if we’re talking about two quite different things. The system cannot be expected to reform itself under moral pressure after all, while the person – we say – can be and absolutely should be. Whilst we accept that a logical system is its bias (is no more than a collection of prejudices) the same is not true for us, we say. We regard ourselves as being different in some essential way.
The same is true for us however – the ego (which is who we understand ourselves to be) is a system made up of cause and effect (which is to say, logical connections) and just as there can never be such a thing as ‘an unbiased system’, so too there can never be such a thing as ‘an ego that is fair’, ‘an ego that is noble and without prejudice’. The very definition of the self or ego is that it is a partisan viewpoint, a viewpoint that seeks to invalidate any other position or stance than the one it happens to be taking and that is – as we have been saying – precisely the case for logic. Logic starts off on a purely arbitrary basis (where one position is as good as any other) and then promotes this stance over everything else. Logic is like a virus, we might say – it replicates its starting-off point tirelessly. It fanatically promotes its starting-off point as if that starting off point were super-special (and something worth getting very excited by) when – really – any basis would have done. The implication of specialness is there in the single-minded, dogmatic fervour that goes with it; we might for example think of 1930’s Nazi Germany at the height of its fascist glory – the path ahead is so very clear that no one can possibly doubt it. The cause is so vital, so urgent, so significant that nothing can be allowed to stand in its way (and so on and so forth) and yet what is being championed so earnestly is the very same tired old formula that is always trotted out on these sad occasions.
The vital importance of the ‘message’ that is being promoted, the ’cause’ that is being served, the ‘destiny’ that is being fulfilled, etc. etc., is only a cheap gimmick, a hastily thrown-together excuse. The really important thing (for us) is that there should be this ‘cause’, that there should be this ‘purpose that we all have to get behind’. It’s the drama we’re interested in, not what the drama is supposedly about. Any old thing will do because we’re never actually going to look into it, because we’re never going to pay any real attention to it. It’s only a token and so there doesn’t have to be anything to it; the whole point of dogmatic fervour is that we never question the dogma, after all. The Complex Universe has been simplified down to the very straightforward matter of ‘Doing the thing’ – no one cares what the thing is or why it’s so super important that we should do it. We just want a pretext for not questioning anything, and that pretext doesn’t have to be anything more than just a hollow token. It doesn’t matter how shoddy the token is because we’re never going to question it anyway. This is how Fascism works and it is also how logic itself is too – the key thing about logic is that it can’t question itself, as we have been saying.
What we’re looking for in all our ‘-isms’, all our fanatical beliefs, is a pretext for immersing ourselves in heedless mechanical activity therefore; we’re running away from actual awareness, we’re running away from any individual responsibility. We absolutely don’t want to have to think about anything, reflect on anything, look into anything, and we have made this militant ignorance into a virtue. We just want to ‘do the thing’ – whatever the thing might be – and gain acceptance from our peers on this basis. We just want to obtain approval from ‘everyone else in the room’ (who are all busy running away from their individual responsibility, just as we are). This isn’t ‘responsibility’ in the sense in which we usually use the word but rather responsibility in the sense of seeing the truth about things ourselves (as opposed to handing this task over to someone else, who can then tell us about it, who can then tell us what we have to do, based on this picture). We all want to be told what to do, we all want to be given the game to play, a game that we can immerse ourselves in. What happens then is that we can happily get on with playing our games of ‘truth avoidance; essentially, we oversimplify life until it becomes a matter of Who is the best at doing ‘the thing’? This is the standard that we’re all measured by; this is how we are defined – both by ourselves and others. Life then becomes a matter of ‘optimisation’. Optimisation doesn’t mean a damn thing, but for us it’s the ‘be all and end all’.
This isn’t just the case for extreme right wing political movements, this is how it works for society in general – society gives us meaningless games to play, and we gladly immerse ourselves in them. To join a social group is to put on to put the group’s agenda above our own; we hand over responsibility for how to live life – which is the ‘Big Question’ – to the crass Collective, thereby relieving ourselves of the need to bother our heads about it. All we need to concern ourselves with is the very practical matter of ‘How to do the socially validated thing’ – that’s all we’re going to be judged on, after all. That’s the only expertise we’re going to need. It doesn’t matter what system it is that we’re talking about because it’s the exact same business in every single case: adapting ourselves to a logical system means immersing ourselves in heedless mechanical activity and that’s all there is to it.
There is zero poetry here, only ‘mere meaningless mechanicalness, only the continual scrabbling to attain a collectively agreed-upon goal (that has absolutely nothing to do with us). To be devoured by the Machine is to be ‘devoured by the machine’ and it doesn’t matter in which particular way this happens. I could be devoured ‘head-first’ or ‘feet-first, but what difference does it make? To put everything I’ve got into the generic task of ‘optimising my performance with regard to the specified set of parameters’ is to define my entire existence, my entire being in terms of some dumb mechanical rule – it hardly matters what that rule is. All rules are after all the same rule, when it comes down to it – all rules (without exception) come down to ‘doing the meaningless thing’ whilst trying to use this heedless goal-driven activity to actually generate meaning, to actually create meaning (as if meaning could ever be ‘created’). This is the modern world in a nutshell – we continuously rave on about ‘goals’ and ‘purposefulness’ whilst studiously avoiding seeing that the world which we have thereby created for ourselves is entirely hollow…
Image credit – thecollector.com
